Toronto Maple Leafs vs Ottawa Senators Picks & Odds – NHL Playoffs Game 1

By Sam Clarke | Not Valid For Ontario
Published on 18 April 2025 | 08:21 - Updated on 21 May 2025 | 06:38

Maple Leafs vs Senators Picks and Odds

Recommended Bets: Maple Leafs vs Senators

​On Sunday, April 20, at 7:00 PM EDT, the Toronto Maple Leafs and Ottawa Senators will face off at Scotiabank Arena in Toronto for Game 1 of their first-round series in the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs. The game will be broadcast live on Sportsnet, CBC, TVAS, and ESPN2.

The Maple Leafs head into the playoffs on a high after managing to beat the Red Wings 4-3 in an overtime battle on Thursday night. It’s been a strong finish to the season, with stars like Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner hitting big milestones and leading the charge. In net, Anthony Stolarz has been rock solid, shutting teams out and giving Toronto a real sense of stability heading into the postseason.

The Senators also had a close game to end out the season. They beat the Hurricanes 7-5 and are sitting on 97 points. They handled the Maple Leafs well during the regular season, winning all three matchups and keeping Toronto’s offense quiet. Ottawa’s defensive game has been sharp, and Linus Ullmark has held it down between the pipes when it matters most.

This is the first time these two have met in the playoffs since 2004, and the rivalry still has plenty of bite. With both teams stacked with talent and looking to make a statement, Game 1 is shaping up to be a must-watch.

Our Selected Prediction for the Match

Maple Leafs Over 3.5 goals

Caesars Logo

Odds +120: Bet $100 and win $220

Place Bet at Caesars

Maple Leafs vs Senators Prediction: Best Odds

The best odds for the Toronto Maple Leafs to win, for a draw or for the Ottawa Senators  to win are shown in green.

Click on the odds to access the offers from each bookmaker.

All odds reflected in the table are correct at the time of publication and are subject to change.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs Ottawa Senators Stats

  • The Ottawa Senators dominated the 2024–25 regular season series, winning all three matchups against the Toronto Maple Leafs. The scores were 3–0 (Nov 12), 2–1 (Jan 25), and 4–2 (Mar 15), marking Ottawa's first season sweep over Toronto since the early 2000s. ​

  • Toronto averaged 3.26 goals per game during the regular season, surpassing Ottawa's 2.95. However, in their head-to-head matchups, the Senators outscored the Leafs 9–3.

  • Toronto's Anthony Stolarz led with a 2.14 GAA and a .926 save percentage, while Ottawa's Linus Ullmark posted a 2.72 GAA and a .910 save percentage.

  • Both teams boast strong power plays with Toronto at 24.8% and Ottawa at 23.7%. However, their penalty kills are nearly identical, with Toronto at 77.9% and Ottawa at 77.7%.

Maple Leafs vs Senators Prediction: Market Selection

The best sportsbook offers across different markets for props, goals, spread and player bets.

Sportsbook

Market

Odds

Bet Now

TonyBet Logo

Both Teams to Score

-1000

Caesars Logo

Maple Leafs Over 3.5 Goals

+120

BETMGM Logo

Maple Leafs -1.5

+165

NorthStarBets Logo

Auston Matthews to Score

-109

Casumo Logo

Over 6.5 Total Goals

+143

BET99 Logo

Overtime? Yes

+310

Third-party payment methods may charge a fee. Deposit and withdrawal times, minimum and maximum amounts are also subject to change. Please check with your payment provider before processing.

Our Betting Recommendation

Toronto should come out swinging. Playing at home and with a point to prove after dropping all three games to Ottawa in the regular season, the Leafs are expected to push the pace from the start. With Matthews, Marner, and Nylander leading the charge, this team knows how to create chances when the pressure is on.

But that aggression opens the door for Ottawa to hit back. The Senators have been patient and effective on the counter, and with Ullmark in net, they don’t need to dominate to stay in the game. That said, Toronto’s firepower and recent form should eventually take over, especially with the energy of Scotiabank Arena behind them. We expect an open game with chances at both ends, but the Leafs should have too much in the tank.

Our betting recommendation: Maple Leafs to win and over 3.5 goals. Prediction: 5–2 Toronto.

FEATURED

TonyBet logo
  • Extensive Esports Betting Markets
  • Can Deposit Using Crypto
  • 24/7 Customer Support
Bet Now
19+. This offer is only available to new players who have made their first deposit and selected this offer as a welcome bonus. All players must be 19+ years old and of legal age to gamble. Make your first qualifying deposit of at least С$15. Place one or more qualifying bets with a total stake of five (5) times your initial qualifying deposit on sports betting markets with odds of at least 1.5 on single bets or multi bets with cumulative odds of 1.7 and higher. Full T&Cs apply.
Casumo logo
  • Competitive Odds
  • Reliable Live Betting
  • Simple Bet Tracking
Bet Now
19+. New customers, outside Ontario only, 1x 100% profit boost, max stake $25, max winnings $1000, min odds 1.50, paid out in cash, no wagering requirements. Please bet responsibly • GamblingTherapy.org T&Cs apply.
NorthStar Bets logo
  • Local Canadian Brand
  • Amazing Odds
  • Daily Promotions
Bet Now
19+ | Play Responsibly | Not available to persons in Ontario
Sports Interaction logo
  • Unique Interface
  • Huge Selection of Sports Markets
  • Competitive Odds
Bet Now
New customers only | Bonus equal to 125% of first deposit up to $250 | Deposit must be made within the first 10 days after opening account | Wager 6 x deposit plus bonus on sports only (min odds restriction applies) | Wagering must be met within 60 days | 19+ Please Play Responsibly
BET99 logo
  • Focus on Canadian Sports
  • Comprehensive Betting Menu
  • Lots of Promotions
Bet Now
19+ | Play Responsibly | Not available to persons in Ontario | Register and make a deposit of at least $20 to qualify for a bonus up to a maximum of $800 on your first deposit. The bonus must be used within 30 days of being granted.

Recommended Sportsbooks

Placeholder Image
WELCOME BONUS

100% Deposit Match up to $350

19+. This offer is only available to new players who have made their first deposit and selected this offer as a welcome bonus. All players must be 19+ years old and of legal age to gamble. Make your first qualifying deposit of at least С$15. Place one or more qualifying bets with a total stake of five (5) times your initial qualifying deposit on sports betting markets with odds of at least 1.5 on single bets or multi bets with cumulative odds of 1.7 and higher. Full T&Cs apply.
Placeholder Image
WELCOME BONUS

100% Deposit Match up to $100

19+ | Play Responsibly | Not available to persons in Ontario
Placeholder Image
WELCOME BONUS

100% Deposit Match up to $1000

19+. New customers, outside Ontario only, 1x 100% profit boost, max stake $25, max winnings $1000, min odds 1.50, paid out in cash, no wagering requirements. Please bet responsibly • GamblingTherapy.org T&Cs apply.
New customers only | Bonus equal to 125% of first deposit up to $250 | Deposit must be made within the first 10 days after opening account | Wager 6 x deposit plus bonus on sports only (min odds restriction applies) | Wagering must be met within 60 days | 19+ Please Play Responsibly
18+ | New customers only | 100% bonus up to $150 on first deposit | Min deposit $30 | Wager 6x deposit + bonus on sports (min odds 2.00 singles or 1.50 multis) | Max $75 per bet counts | Must be completed within 30 days | Skrill/Neteller excluded | 18+ Terms apply
Placeholder Image
WELCOME BONUS

Get $50 in Free Bets

18+. This offer is not available for players residing in Ontario. New Customer Offer. T&C’s Apply.
Placeholder Image
WELCOME BONUS

100% Deposit Match up to $800

19+ | Play Responsibly | Not available to persons in Ontario |  Register and make a deposit of at least $20 to qualify for a bonus up to a maximum of $800 on your first deposit. The bonus must be used within 30 days of being granted.